How to Negotiate with Clients: The Uncomfortable Truth About Getting What You Deserve

Connect with us: SB Nation | Doodle or Die | Morguefile | Evernote

There I was, sitting across from a potential client who'd just asked me to cut my training fee by 40% "because times are tough." This was the same bloke who'd driven up in a Range Rover and spent the first ten minutes telling me about his recent ski trip to Aspen. That moment crystallised something I'd been avoiding for years: most of us are absolutely terrible at negotiating, not because we lack skills, but because we're scared of being disliked.

Here's what nobody tells you about client negotiations – it's not about winning or losing. It's about respect.

The Fundamental Shift Most People Miss

After seventeen years of running workplace training programmes across Melbourne, Sydney, and Perth, I've watched hundreds of business owners sabotage themselves in negotiations. They treat it like a battle when it should be a dance. They focus on tactics when they should focus on value.

The real problem? We've been conditioned to believe that asking for what we're worth makes us greedy. Rubbish.

Good negotiations create better relationships, not worse ones. When you negotiate properly, your clients respect you more, pay you more, and refer you more often. The ones who don't? Well, they weren't your ideal clients anyway.

Why Australian Business Culture Makes This Harder

We're raised to be modest. "Tall poppy syndrome" isn't just a saying – it's embedded in our DNA. We apologise for our expertise, discount our value, and feel guilty about charging what we're worth. I see this constantly in corporate communication skills training sessions where participants physically cringe when practicing assertive language.

But here's the thing: your international competitors aren't playing by these rules.

I remember working with a consultancy firm in Brisbane whose founder kept losing contracts to overseas providers. Not because his work was inferior – it was brilliant – but because he presented his proposals like apologies. "I hope this isn't too expensive, but..." versus "Here's the investment required for exceptional results."

Same service. Different positioning. Completely different outcomes.

The Three Negotiation Mistakes That Cost You Thousands

Mistake #1: Starting with Price Instead of Value

Most people open negotiations by talking about their rates. Wrong move. Dead wrong.

Start with outcomes. What's the cost of not solving their problem? What's the value of getting it right? I learned this the hard way after losing a major contract to someone charging double my rate. Their secret? They spent forty minutes discussing the client's pain points before mentioning money.

Mistake #2: Accepting the First "No" as Final

Research shows that 78% of purchasing decisions involve at least three touch points. Yet most of us fold after the first pushback. When a client says "it's too expensive," they're not necessarily saying no. They're asking you to justify the investment.

Try this instead: "I understand budget is a consideration. Help me understand what outcome would make this investment feel worthwhile to you?"

Mistake #3: Negotiating Against Yourself

This drives me absolutely mental. You present your price, they go quiet for thirty seconds, and you immediately start offering discounts. Stop it. The silence isn't rejection – it's processing.

Some of the best deals I've closed happened after uncomfortable pauses. Let them think. Let them calculate. Let them come back with questions instead of assumptions.

The Psychology Behind Effective Negotiation

Here's where most negotiation advice gets it wrong. It's not about manipulation or psychological tricks. It's about understanding what drives decision-making.

People buy from people they trust. They negotiate with people they respect. And they pay premium prices to people who make them feel confident about their decision.

The best negotiators I know have mastered something called "confident humility." They're absolutely certain about their value while remaining genuinely curious about the client's needs. It's emotional intelligence training in action.

This means asking better questions:

• "What would success look like for you?"
• "What's happened when you've tried to solve this internally?"
• "What's the cost of delaying this decision?"

Notice how none of these are about you? That's intentional.

Real-World Strategies That Actually Work

The Bracket Approach

Instead of giving one price, present three options. Basic, standard, premium. Psychology research confirms that most people choose the middle option, which should be your target price anyway. The premium option makes your preferred choice seem reasonable.

The Deadline Strategy

Not artificial urgency – genuine scarcity. "I have capacity for one more project this quarter" or "This proposal is valid until Friday because my costs increase with the new financial year." Truth with urgency beats fake deadlines every time.

The Partnership Frame

Change the language from "vendor/client" to "partnership." Instead of "Here's what I charge," try "Here's how we can structure this investment." It's subtle but powerful.

I was working with a manufacturing company in Adelaide that was struggling with managing difficult conversations training for their supervisors. Instead of presenting a standard workshop proposal, I reframed it as a partnership to reduce workplace conflicts and improve productivity. Same content, different positioning. They paid 60% more because they saw it as an investment in their culture, not just training.

When Negotiations Go Wrong (And How to Recover)

Sometimes you miscalculate. Sometimes they have genuinely limited budgets. Sometimes you're just not the right fit.

The key is knowing when to walk away gracefully and when to find creative solutions.

I once had a startup offer me equity instead of cash for a leadership programme. Normally, I'd say no immediately. But I believed in their vision, liked the founders, and had some free time between major projects. That equity stake ended up being worth more than my usual fee when they sold three years later.

The point isn't to always say yes to alternative arrangements. It's to stay open to possibilities while maintaining your boundaries.

The Follow-Up That Seals the Deal

Here's something that separates amateur negotiators from professionals: the follow-up.

Most people send a generic "thanks for your time" email. Waste of pixels.

Instead, summarise what you heard, confirm the next steps, and include one piece of additional value. An article relevant to their industry. A contact who might help with a challenge they mentioned. Something that shows you were listening and thinking beyond the immediate transaction.

This isn't manipulation – it's genuine relationship building. And it works because so few people do it.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Pricing

Here's what nobody wants to admit: you're probably undercharging.

I know that sounds self-serving coming from someone who sells training, but hear me out. When I first started my consultancy, I charged what I thought people could afford rather than what my results were worth. Big mistake.

Clients who pay premium prices are more committed to implementation. They value your expertise more highly. They're less likely to waste your time or question your methods. Counter-intuitive? Maybe. True? Absolutely.

The sweet spot isn't the lowest price the market will bear – it's the highest price your confidence can justify.

Making It Stick: Implementation Strategies

Knowing negotiation theory is useless without practice. Start small. Negotiate with suppliers, contractors, even subscription services. Build your comfort level with smaller stakes before tackling major client conversations.

Role-play difficult scenarios. Record yourself making proposals. Get feedback from peers. Communication training isn't just for your staff – it's for you too.

And remember: every "no" is data. What objections keep coming up? Where are you losing people? What questions catch you off-guard? Use this intelligence to refine your approach.

The clients worth having will respect your professionalism and clear boundaries. The ones who don't? Well, they're probably not going to be great clients anyway.

Stop apologising for your expertise. Start asking for what you're worth. Your future self will thank you.